-
WCM Industries, Inc. v. IPS Corporation et al DC CAFC
- 2:13-cv-02019
- W.D. Tenn.
- Judge: Jon Phipps McCalla +1
- Filed: 01/09/2013
- Closed: 03/29/2019
- Latest Docket Entry: 05/27/2020
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
1
Plaintiff
2
Defendants
2
Accused
Products
8
Patents-in-Suit
2,271
Days in
Litigation
-
WCM Industries, Inc. v. IPS Corporation et al DC CAFC
- 2:13-cv-02019
- W.D. Tenn.
- Judge: Jon Phipps McCalla +1
- Filed: 01/09/2013
- Closed: 03/29/2019
- Latest Docket Entry: 05/27/2020
- PACER
- Docket updated daily
Assigned Judge
Outcome Summary
- Patent Information
-
Validity & Enforceability
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
12 |
An overflow assembly adapted for interconnection to a bathtub, which has a bottom, side walls, end walls, and an overflow port in one end wall, comprising: an overflow pipe with an elbow portion defining an upper end portion and a lower end portion,
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 454 |
13 |
The assembly of claim 12, wherein said nut element and said radially extending lugs constitute a single-piece unit.
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 454 |
Claim # | Claim Text | Outcome |
---|---|---|
11 |
A plumbing system for interconnection with a bathtub that has an overflow port and a drain port, comprising: an overflow assembly adapted for interconnection to a bathtub, which has a bottom, side walls, end walls, and the overflow port in one end
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 454 |
12 |
A plumbing system for interconnection with a bathtub that has an overflow port and a drain port, comprising: an overflow assembly for a bathtub, comprising: an overflow pipe having a flange, the overflow port adapted to be associated with a threaded
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 454 |
13 |
A plumbing system for interconnection with a bathtub that has an overflow port and a drain port, the plumbing system also associated with a waste water strainer, said strainer having a cylindrical wall with a bottom edge surrounding a cylindrical
view more
|
Invalid (102)
Entry 454 |
-
Infringement
IPS Corporation
- 8 Details
Accused Product | Patent # | Claim # | Outcome |
---|---|---|---|
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US 8,166,584 B2 | All Asserted Claims |
Infringement
Entry 776
|
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US 8,302,220 B2 |
12, 13
|
Willful infringement
Entry 454Entry 776 |
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US 8,321,970 B2 |
1
|
Willful infringement
Entry 454Entry 776 |
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US 8,505,132 B2 | All Asserted Claims |
Infringement
Entry 776
|
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US 8,584,272 B2 |
11, 12, 13
|
Willful infringement
Entry 454Entry 776 |
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US D627,863 S1 | All Asserted Claims |
Infringement
Entry 776
|
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US D636,468 S1 | All Asserted Claims |
Infringement
Entry 776
|
CLASSICClassic with a twist | US D665,062 S1 | All Asserted Claims |
Infringement
Entry 776
|
-
Damages
Total Damages:
$4,982,985.00Other Costs:
$264,196.93Dockets:
- Reasonable Royalty: $153,476.00
- Compensatory Damages: $1,655,008.00
- Enhanced Damages: $3,174,501.00
- Attorney Fees: $60,535.50
- Court Costs: $89,902.94
- Pre Judgment Interest: $113,758.49